HomeMy WebLinkAbout20 Electric Master Plan Agenda Item # 20
�s
E , DONNER
Public Utility District
Action
To: Board of Directors
From: Joe Horvath
Date: June 4, 2008
Subject: Award Electric System Master Plan Contract
1. WHY THIS MATTER IS BEFORE THE BOARD
Only the Board can approve bid awards over$15,000.
2. HISTORY
At the March 13, 2008 Board meeting, a workshop was presented to discuss the Electric
System Master Plan study and the proposed RFP process. The last comprehensive Master Plan
study was prepared in 1993 with an update completed in 2002. The updated study formed the
basis for recent modifications to electric facility fees. District policy is to update the Master Plan
every five years, therefore funds were budgeted and the RFP process was started to retain a
consultant. The RFP period began on March 22, 2008 and ended on April 25, 2008. The District
received 5 proposals by the deadline from the following consultants: CVO Electrical Systems,
Electrical Consultants, Inc., HDR Engineering, R.W. Beck, and Stanley Consultants.
3. NEW INFORMATION
After receipt of the Proposals, a review committee was formed composed of the following
District staff: Sanna Schlosser, Steve Hollabaugh, Neil Kaufman, Steve Trevino and Joe
Horvath. The committee members scored the Technical Proposals using specific criteria to
maintain consistency among members. The Technical Proposal was worth 85 percent of the
overall score. The Cost Proposals were opened after the committee completed the review and
ranking process of the Technical Proposals. The Cost Proposal was worth 15 percent of the
overall score.
The committee members were unanimous in their ranking of RW Beck as the most technically
qualified consultant. The Cost Proposals were then opened and ranked assigning the full 15
points to the lowest price consultant and assigning zero points to the highest price consultant.
The remaining consultants were assigned points by prorating their costs compared to the lowest
and highest prices. The ranking of the consultants including technical, cost, and total scores are
as follows:
1
Consultant Tech. Score Cost Score Total Score
RW Beck 69 6 75
Electrical Consultants 63 15 78
CVO Electrical Systems 59 4 63
HDR Consultants 52 8 60
Stanley Consultants 46 0 46
RW Beck was the highest ranked consultant on a technical basis, and their price to perform the
work was $113,936. Electrical Consultants was the next highest technically ranked consultant
but with a price of $69,868. After the costs were converted to scores based on a 15 point scale,
Electrical Consultants had the highest overall score (see attached Proposal Cost Estimate).
4. FISCAL IMPACT
The source of funding for the Electric System Master Plan study is Facilities Fees for those
portions of the study which lead to the development of capital improvement plans. The
remainder must be paid from Rates. If the Board approves retaining Electrical Consultants Inc.
as the consultant, the cost breakdown for engineering services for the Master Plan study would
be as follows:
Facility Fees $51,914
Rates $17,954
Total Cost $69,868
Funding for the Master Plan study in the approved FY 2008 budget is $71,900.
5. RECOMMENDATION:
That the Board approve the selection of Electrical Consultants Inc. to provide professional
engineering services to the District for the Electric System Master Plan study and authorize the
Board President to sign the consulting services agreement for an amount not to exceed $69,868
with the funding sources as noted above.
4;Z114 - /".a,
Stephen Hollabaugh, Assistant General Michael D. Holley, General Manager
Manager
2
TDPUD-Fffteen 95 Year Electrical Master Plan Study Ect/EngineBring Estimate
DM RH PB HV SF Be
PROJECTTASKS Billing Project Project Project Planning
Group Supervisor Manager Engineer Technician Dre Stano
Section Summary
P1 Initial Data Collection and Historical Review $6,566 4 30 a 36 0 14
P2 Planning Criteria $1,040 2 8 0 0 0 0
3 Analysis of the Existing System and hnniediate Improvement Plan $12,322 4 56 30 74 0 0
P4 Prepare Load Forecast $7,756 4 40 0 60 0 0
Ps Long Range System Planning $12,552 12 80 12 40 0 0
P8 Protective Device Coordination Study $5,632 16 16 32 0 0 0
Py Comprehensive,Master Phan Report $16,300 a 60 0 56 80 60
TOTALS-ALL SECTIONS $62.15316o 290 _82 1 266 1 0 74
RATE FOR PERSONNEL CLASSIFICATION $104.00 $104.00 $72.00 s83.00 $49,00 $39.00
TOTAL COSTS Sy PERSONNEL CLASSIFICATION i#S.00 530180 t5,904 S14 088 t3 920 tllt6
Total Engineering and No $62,168
Travel Motel Meals Rentals Copies Software
Estimated Direct Expenses $3,600 $900 $600 $00 $500 S1,ao0
Total Direct Casts: $7,700
Estimated Fees: $69,868.00
Contingency: 0% $0.00
Total Estimated Fees: $49,868.00
i
k
f
i
l
P;1Project ManagementtEngineering Estimates12008 Electrical Master Plan Proposal Cost Esumate.x)sx 3 013