Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout#16 Post Retirement Benefits AGENDA ITEM #16 Public Utility District m MEETING DATE: May 1, 2024 TO: Board of Directors FROM: Jillian Steward, Human Resources Director Brian Wright, General Manager SUBJECT: District Code Title 4, Post Retirement Benefits APPROVED BY: Brian C. Wright, General Manager RECOMMENDATION: A.) Approve a revision to District Code, Title 4 Personnel, as proposed on March 6, 2024, to limit the eligibility of negotiated employee group benefit adjustments made effective January 1, 2024 to current employees and those who have retired after January 1, 2024; or B) Approve a revision to District Code, Title 4 Personnel to make current and all retired employees eligible for negotiated employee group benefit adjustments made effective January 1, 2024 BACKGROUND: District Code, Title 4 Personnel codifies group benefits for all regular employees who are not represented by a Union Memorandum of Understanding (MOU), as well as other personnel policies. As part of the unrepresented employees group compensation negotiations, certain benefit changes are proposed from year to year. At the Board's regularly scheduled meeting held on March 6, 2024, staff presented for Board consideration Item #14, Consideration of Approval of Employee Benefits Changes. Employee benefits for District employees are outlined in District Code, Title 4. The proposed changes to the benefits outlined in Title 4 included: 1. 4.07.020.3 Changing the vision plan benefit from $400 to $500 per covered employee or dependent; 2. 4.07.050, for retiree's vision benefit, specifying the increase to $500 is for retirees with retirements effective 1/1/2024 or later; 3. 4.07.010.1, for paid sick leave cash-out, reducing the minimum accrued sick hours from 600 to 500 hours; Page 1 of 4 Page 67 of 215 4. 4.07.035, adding documentation of the 457B District match and increasing the match by 2.0% compared to the current level; 5. 4.07.090, changing the administrative leave benefit from 9 days to 10 days; 6. 4.07.020.6, adding a new Wellness benefit program, a FY24 budgeted benefit addition At the March 6, 2024 Board Meeting, the Board evaluated each of the modifications to employee benefits, approving all as proposed except for modification #2 related to post- retirement benefits and the application of increased benefits to employees who have retired prior to January 1, 2024. The Board provided feedback to staff, requesting additional information and an opportunity to review at a future Board Meeting. During the Board's discussion and review of the proposed changes on March 6, 2024, it was acknowledged that the Board had previously reviewed the same subject matter at a meeting held on May 20, 2020, during the review and determination in response to a Letter of Referral (grievance) submitted by the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers (IBEW), Local 1245, disputing the District's interpretation of post retirement benefits outlined in the recently approved 2020-2024 Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with IBEW. As indicated in the approved Board Minutes from the May 20, 2020 meeting (Attachment 1), the Board made a motion and approved staff's recommendation to reject the grievance submitted by IBEW Local 1245. Additionally, reflected in the minutes of the May 20, 2020 Meeting, the Board provided feedback that staff's interpretation of the MOU and District Code Title 4 was correct, and that negotiated increases in employee benefits were applicable to current employees, future retirees, and not previously retired employees. ANALYSIS AND BODY: As indicated previously in this staff report, at the March 6, 2024 Board Meeting, the Board requested that staff bring the item back for further consideration at a future meeting date, providing the opportunity to more fully review the issue, past discussion, and the financial impacts. One of the key points of discussion on March 6th was the fact that while the Board made a determination at the May 20, 2020, meeting to reject the grievance submitted by IBEW 1245 and uphold staff's interpretation of both District Code Title 4 and the MOU as it pertains to employee benefits, District Code Title 4 was not revised in any manner to reflect this determination. Staff's recommendation with this item is for the Board to make a determination as to the application of recently negotiated increases in group benefits of previously employed retirees. In response to the Board of Director's request for additional information and for consideration, the following items have been included as attachments to this staff report: 1. Staff Report for the March 6, 2024 Agenda, Item #14; Page 2 of 4 Page 68 of 215 2. Staff Report for the May 20, 2020 Agenda, Item #12; 3. Board approved minutes for the May 20, 2020 Meeting GOALS AND OBJECTIVES: District Code 1 .05.020 Objectives: 1. Responsibly serve the public. 2. Provide a healthy and safe work environment for all District employees. 3. Provide reliable and high quality water supply and distribution system to meet current and future needs. 4. Provide reliable and high quality electric supply and distribution system to meet current and future needs. 5. Manage the District in an environmentally sound manner. 6. Manage the District in an effective, efficient and fiscally responsible manner. District Code 1 .05.030 Goals: 1. Manage for Financial Stability and Resiliency 2. Environmental Stewardship: Create a sustainable resilient environment for all our communities. 3. Engage with our customers and communities in a welcoming and transparent way to identify opportunities. 4. Take the best of private sector thinking to modernize the utility and add value to our communities. 5. Developing an inclusive culture drives organizational integration and success. FISCAL IMPACT: The application of recently negotiated changes to employee group benefits was not included in the District's FY2024-2025 Board approved budget. As of January 1, 2024 there are 48 retired former District employees actively receiving post-retirement benefits. Including retired employee's qualifying spouse and dependents, there are 88 participants in the District's post-retirement benefit program. The District's total cost of active participants in post-retirement benefits are as follows: • Medical Benefits o $378,803 (Total annual cost of current participants prior to application of an approved increase) o $460,267 (Estimated total annual cost of current participants including application of approved benefits increase) o $81,464 (Equivalent to a 22% increase in the District's total annual cost of post-retirement medical benefits) Page 3 of 4 Page 69 of 215 • Vision Benefits o $12,243 (2023 total post-retirement vision care payment) o $16,943 (Estimated total cost in annual post-retirement vision care benefits o $4,700 (Equivalent to a 38% increase in the District's total annual post- retirement vision care benefits) The application of recently negotiated increases in group benefits (Medical and Vision) would result in an increase of the District's total estimated post-retirement benefit cost of approximately $86,164. NOTE: This change would have a material impact on the District's OPEB net liability valuation which as of 12/31/2023 was $5.97M. An increase in the liability would be a non-cash expense charge and result in a corresponding decrease in, the Net Position of the District. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Attachment #1, March 6, 2024 Staff Report, Item #14 2. Attachement #2, Staff Report May 20, 2020 Item #12 3. Attachment #3, May 20, 2020 Board Minutes Page 4 of 4 Page 70 of 215 AGENDA ITEM #14 F��r Public Utility District MEETING DATE: March 6, 2024 TO: Board of Directors FROM: Jillian Steward, Human Resources Director Michael Salmon, Chief Financial Officer SUBJECT: Consideration of Approval of Employee Benefits Changes APPROVED BY: Brian C. Wright, General Manager RECOMMENDATION: Approve Resolution 2024-04 amending District Code - Title 4 Personnel as presented in Attachment 1, which provides modifications to employee benefits. BACKGROUND: District Code, Title 4 Personnel codifies group benefits for all regular employees who are not represented by a Union Memorandum of Understanding (MOU), as well as other personnel policies. As part of the unrepresented employees group compensation negotiations for 2024, certain benefit changes have been identified. Revisions to Title 4 are accomplished by a Resolution adopted by the Board. ANALYSIS AND BODY: In summary, approval of Resolution 2024-04 (attachment 1) amending District Code, Title 4 provides for the following revisions: 1 4.07.020.3, changing the vision plan benefit from $400 to $500 per covered employee or dependent 2 4.07.050, for retiree's vision benefit, specifying the change to $500 is for retirees with retirements effective 1/1/2024 or later. 3 4.07.101.1, for paid sick leave cash-out, reducing the minimum accrued sick hours from 600 to 500 hours 4 4.07.035, adding documentation of the 457B District match and increasing the match by 2.0% compared to the current level 5 4.07.090, changing the administrative leave benefit from 9 days to 10 days (formalizing in District Code the effective 1/1/2023 board previously approved change) 6 4.07.020.6, adding a new Wellness benefit program, a FY24 budgeted benefit addition Attachment 2 provides a red-line above within the complete Title 4 text. Below is information regarding each of the above-noted benefit changes. Page 1 of 4 Page 71 of 215 1. Increase the vision benefit from $400 to $500 per employee and dependent. The vision benefit has been $400 per year per eligible participant for decades, and has not adjusted for inflation. The increase of$100 is estimated to have an annual cost increase impact of $14,000 (all Employees/Retirees). Resolution 2024-04 provides the update to 4.07.020.3 Vision Plan dollar amount per participant. 2. For Post-Retirement Health Benefits (4.07.050) specifies the change to $500 is only for retirees retiring after 11112024. Therefore, the benefit remains $400 per year for all current retirees and dependents who are eligible. 3. Paid Sick Leave cash-out currently has a minimum balance threshold of 600 hours. Unrepresented employees recommend reducing this policy to 500 hours. There are currently 6 employees with more than 600 hours of sick time accrued, and 3 with between 500 and 600 hours. Cashing out hours is an elective/optional matter from a cash flow basis. On an accounting basis, this change is estimated to have a one-time expense charge of$27,500 (non-cash). 4. Effective 7/01/23, CalPERS increased the required PEPRA employee contribution rate from 6.75% to 7.75%, a 1% increase. To offset this increase, which would have resulted in an additional 1% deduction in a PEPRA employee's paycheck, the District reduced the minimum contribution to the employees' 457b plan by 1%, from 6.28% to 5.28% effective 7/01/23. The District's retirement plan for PEPRA employees includes a match of the 457b minimum contribution into a 401 a plan, so this match was also reduced by 1%, 6.28% to 5.28% effective 7/01/23. These changes were made based on the intent of the PEPRA members section of the Memorandum of Understanding with IBEW 1245, section 19.2(h) Retirement Plans. The total impact of these changes to PEPRA employees is that they are now paying 1% more into the pension program for the same benefit and lost a 1% contribution match, a total of a 2% loss in their retirement benefit. As of January 2024, the District's employee CalPERS pension participant mix is 69% PEPRA to 31% CLASSIC, therefore this change is affecting the majority of our staff. On 7/01/23 The District's retirement cost for PEPRA employees increased 0.21% to 7.68% and the District's contribution to the 401 a match decreased 1% to 5.28%, resulting in a net change of a decrease of 0.79% to a total contribution for PEPRA employees of 12.96% of wages. The District's total contribution for CLASSIC member employees is currently 15.17% of wages. Resolution 2024-04 provides new section as follows: 4.07.035 PEPRA Members — Employee and District Contributions a) The CaIPERs contributions by the Employee and District are determined by the annual actuarial valuation reports issued annually in July by CalPERS. b) 457(b) or 401(a) Plan Contributions — 1. Employee shall pay a percentage of wages equal to 13.03% minus the employee contribution in a) above. 2. District shall pay a percentage of wages equal to 13.03% minus the employee contribution in a) above plus 2.0%; subject to a maximum combined rate of District CalPERS contribution in a) above and b) District contribution shall not exceed the Classic pension District contribution rate. Page 2 of 4 Page 72 of 215 Below summarizes the above information in table form Current Proposed To 2020 FYE 6130 to 613012024 FYE 6130 2019 to 2023 2024 eff.11112024 2025 PEPRA member of CalPERS Pension: Employee CalPERS Contribution 6.25% 6.75% 7.75% 7.75% 7.75% Def.Comp.457(b)Contrib.(Req.Minimum) 6.78% 6.28% 5.28% 5.28% 5.28% Combined Retirement Paid by Employee,PEPRA 13.03% 13.03% 13.03% 13.03% 13.03% for ref.Classic,required contribution by Employee 8.00% 8.00% 8.00% 8.00% 8.00% PEPRA member of CalPERS Pension: DISTRICT CalPERS Contribution(varies slightly by year) 6.84% 7A7% 7.68% 7.68% 7.87% Def.Comp.401(a)Contribution 6.76% 6.28% 5.28% 7.28% 7.28% Combined Retirement Paid by Employer 13.62% 13.76% 12.96% 14.96% 15.15% for ref.Classic,required conbrbution by District 11.57% 13,35% 15.17% 15.17% 15.24% Excludes C LASSIC UAL($1 Am for 2025) 5. In FY23 for 2023 and forward, the Board approved an increase in the administrative leave benefit for unrepresented employees; changing the administrative leave benefit from 9 days to 10 days. Revising 4.07.090 formalizes Title 4 for this effective 1/1/2023 previously board approved change. 6. The approved FY24 FY25 budget included a new wellness benefit program. The addition of chapter 4.07.020.6 to Title 4 codifies this new benefit program at up to $500 per year per active employee and active board director. The unrepresented employee group benefit changes are recommended to be effective 11112024. Staff recommends the benefit items outlined in this report to be in alignment with MOU represented and unrepresented employees in 2024. For represented (MOU) employees, these benefit items are pending review by IBEW Local 1245 and will require a letter of agreement for amendments to the MOU. GOALS AND OBJECTIVES: District Code 1.05.020 Objectives: 2. Provide a healthy and safe work environment for all District employees. 6. Manage the District in an effective, efficient and fiscally responsible manner. District Code 1.05.030 Goals: 1. Manage for Financial Stability and Resiliency 5. Developing an inclusive culture drives organizational integration and success. FISCAL IMPACT: Page 3 of 4 Page 73 of 215 Below are the financial impacts for all employees (ie assumes the represented employee group to align with the unrepresented employee group, as applicable). Items 1 and 2, the vision benefit change equates to an estimated $14,000 annual cost impact. Item 3, the paid sick leave cash-out is estimated to have a nominal cash outflow impact and $27,500 non-cash expense cost charge. Item 4, the PEPRA district's contribution increase of 2.0% is estimated to have a 2024 impact of $137,800. Item 5, administrative leave benefit increase of one day, was previously approved by the Board, included in Budget for FY24 & FY25 and has no incremental cost impact. Item 6, new wellness benefit, was included in FY24 and FY25 budget, $35,000 and $37,500 respectively. The District's operating reserves of$6.51M Electric and $7.7M Water are sufficient to fund above items 1 to 4 non-budgeted impacts. ATTACHMENTS: 1. R2024-04 Adopting Amendments to District Code Title 4 2. Title 4 Personnel - 2020-04 Page 4 of 4 Page 74 of 215 TRUCKEE r Publ'IC Utility District Resolution No. 2024-04 ADOPTING AMENDMENTS TO DISTRICT CODE TITLE 4 WHEREAS, TITLE 4 PERSONNEL of District Code provides personnel general personnel policies and provisions for Employee Benefits; and WHEREAS, the Board of Directors of the Truckee Donner Public Utility District wishes to amend the District Code Title 4 to account for updated provisions in employee benefits; and WHEREAS, it is the Board's desire to amend District Code Title 4 Personnel to specify certain benefit items, effective 1/1/2024 (unless stated otherwise) and so, NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Board of Directors of the Truckee Donner Public Utility District to authorize the following amendments to District Code Title 4: 1) 4.07.020.3 shall be amended to modify the vision benefit from $400 to $500 2) 4.07.035 of Title 4 shall be added and read as follows: 4.07.035 PEPRA Members — Em Io ee and District Contributions a) CalPers Contributions by the Employee and District are determined by the annual actuarial valuation reports issued annually in July. b) 457(b) or 401(a) Plan Contributions — 1. Employee shall pay a percentage of wages equal to 13.03% minus the employee contribution in a) above. 2. District shall pay a percentage of wages equal to 13.03% minus the employee contribution in a) above plus 2.0%; subject to a maximum combined rate of District CalPERS contribution in a) above and b)2 District contribution shall not exceed the Classic pension District contribution rate. 3) 4.07.050 Post-Retirement Health Benefits, the next to last sentence shall be amended (amendments in italics) to read as follows: The vision benefit will remain the same without any monthly caps; with retirements effective on or before December 31, 2023 at the $400 per eligible individual benefit level and employee retirements effective post-12131/2023 at the $500 per eligible individual benefit level. 4) 4,07.010.1 Paid Sick Leave Cash-Out Plan, , to change the 600 hours limit to 500 hours 5) 4.07.090 of Title 4 shall be amended to change administrative leave benefit from 9 Page 75 of 215 days to 10 days per calendar year. This item effective 1/112023. 6) 4.07.020.6, adding new Wellness benefit program, a FY24 budgeted benefit addition. Attachment 1 to this Resolution 2024-4 (attachment 2 of staff report) provides complete District Code Title 4 including the full wording of changes referenced above in items A. through E. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Board of Directors of the Truckee Donner Public Utility District at a meeting held within said District on March 6, 2024 by the following roll call vote: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: TRUCKEE DONNER PUBLIC UTILITY DISTRICT BYw..- - - Jeff Bender, President ATTEST: Brian Wright, General Manager Page 76 of 215 Agenda Item # 12 DONNER o;P1 - ACTION To: Board of Directors From: Brian Wright Date: May 20, 2020 Subject: Consideration of Letter of Referral Submitted by IBEW 1245 Regarding MOU Grievance 1. WHY THIS MATTER IS BEFORE THE BOARD Step 3 of Section 14.4,Grievance Procedure Steps, of Title 14, Grievance Procedure of the Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) between the District and IBEW 1245 includes provisions for the Board's written response to a grievance submitted by an employee or an employee organization official if desired by the employee. 2. HISTORY The majority of the District's operations, maintenance and administrative staff (non- exempt employees) is a bargaining unit that is represented by the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers (IBEW) Local 1245. The District and IBEW 1245 have maintained a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) since May 1, 1967. The previous MOU with IBEW Local 1245 became effective on January 1, 2016 and expired on December 31, 2019. In November and December of 2019, the District's labor negotiating team met with IBEW business representatives and the Local 1245 negotiating committee (District bargaining unit employees) to negotiate the terms of the new MOU. On December 12, 2019 the District and IBEW arrived at a tentative agreement on all proposed modifications, pending ratification by majority vote from IBEW Local 1245 membership and approval by the Board. In the interest of honoring the tentative agreement, all of the new provisions within the MOU were implemented and made effective January 1, 2020. On February 5, 2020, IBEW 1245 submitted a grievance to the District on the grounds that the District failed to uphold the terms of Title 19, Employee Benefit Program. The grievance reveals a material difference in interpretation by the District and IBEW Local 1245 as to the applicability of the MOU to previously retired employees of the District. Page 77 of 215 District staff holds the position that during negotiations, compensation and benefits are provisions that were negotiated on behalf of current employees only. IBEW 1245 represents the bargaining unit, which is comprised of current employees. It does not include former employees, including those who have retired from the District. Therefore, District staff had no expectation or reasonable basis upon which to believe that in negotiating with IBEW 1245 that it was negotiating compensation and benefits for anyone other than those persons who are members of the bargaining unit. In other words, there was no expectation or basis upon which to believe that it was bargaining for benefits for anyone who is not a member of the bargaining unit, i.e. - retirees.. At no point during the negotiations did the IBEW 1245, the District's negotiating team or the Board of Directors indicate or suggest that any of the negotiations were being conducted on behalf of non-bargaining unit or previous employees. In the context of the grievance submitted by IBEW 1245 on April 14th, this includes increases in the District's monthly contribution to post retirement benefits. This holds true with other negotiated provisions such as wage increases, increases in employee monthly contributions to group medical insurance plans and other economic benefits. On February 20, 2020, the District and IBEW 1245 held an informal meeting to discuss the difference in interpretation of Title 19, and its potential impact on the timely approval of the MOU. Neither party conceded its position in terms of the applicability of newly negotiated benefits to previously retired employees. Subsequent to this meeting, a second informal meeting was held between the District and IBEW 1245 with the intent of finding resolution to the disputed item and proceed with the timely approval of the new MOU. In this meeting both parties agreed that advisory arbitration, as provided in Title 14 of the MOU, was the appropriate means for seeking resolution. The parties entered into a "Side Letter Agreement" whereby they agreed to resolve their difference without further meet and confer and by allowing the Board to adopt the proposed MOU without either party waiving its respective position on the disputed issue. The Side Letter Agreement has been included with this staff report as Attachment 2. Following final review, IBEW ratified the proposed MOU on February 25, 2020. At the March 18, 2020 meeting, the Board approved the MOU and acknowledged the Side Letter Agreement. 3. NEW INFORMATION On April 14, 2020 the District received a second grievance from IBEW 1245 that was substantially the same as the grievance received on February 5, 2020. The Grievance received from IBEW 1245 on April 14, 2020 has been included with this Staff Report as Attachment 1 . In accordance with Step 2 of the Grievance Procedures outlined in Title 14 of the MOU, the District responded to IBEW 1245 on April 15, 2020, stating Page 78 of 215 that the District's position on the disputed item had not changed and that subsequent to the initial grievance submitted on February 5, 2020, both parties had agreed to find resolution through advisory arbitration. On May 5, 2020, in accordance with Step 3 of the Grievance Procedures outlined in Title 14 of the MOU, IBEW 1245 submitted to the Board a Letter of Referral for consideration of the grievance submitted on April 14, 2020. The Letter of Referral has been included with this Staff Report as Attachment 2. Not only was the Letter of Referral submitted in contravention of the Side Letter Agreement, it was submitted the day before the May 6, 2020 Board meeting and after the agenda for the meeting had been posted. Therefore, the Board would not have been able to hear and decide on the Letter of Referral within 10 days as required by the MOU. Regardless of the fact that it was submitted in contravention of the Side Letter Agreement, the District informed IBEW 1245 that if it wanted the Board to consider the Referral Letter, it would need to waive the 10-day period in writing. IBEW 1245 waived the 10-day period. A copy of the District's letter and IBEW 1245's response are included with this Staff Report as Attachments 3 and 4, respectively. It should be noted that there are multiple inaccuracies within the Letter of Referral, most significantly: • In paragraph 5 of the letter, IBEW 1245 Business Representative, Mike Venturino indicates that during an informal meeting held on February 20, 2020 "Mr. Holley conveyed in confidence that the cancellation of payment to current retirees was due to outside pressure from unrepresented retirees." This is entirely inaccurate. During the meeting, IBEW 1245 was informed that the previous retirees were never intended to receive the increased post retirement benefit, that Staff had mistakenly distributed the increased contributions to existing retirees in January 2020, and once the mistake was identified, the contribution amounts were corrected. Furthermore, IBEW 1245 was informed that former unrepresented retirees were in fact collaborating with former union retirees to protest the action jointly. The options under consideration by the Board include the following: 1.) Reject the grievance submitted by IBEW 1245 on April 14, 2020, at which point IBEW 1245 would have the option, in accordance with Step 4 of the Grievance Procedures outlined in Title 14 of the MOU, to submit the grievance to non-binding advisory arbitration within twenty (20) days. The arbitrator shall then provide a written recommendation to the Board. The Board would then have ten (10) days to provide a final written decision; or Page 79 of 215 2.) Accept the grievance submitted by IBEW 1245 as valid, thereby affirming the position that IBEW 1245 represents past employees and direct staff to increase the District's post retirement medical benefit contributions for existing employees, effective January 1, 2020. In making a determination as to how to proceed in this matter, the Board may wish to consider some of the following contributing factors: • Generally speaking, labor negotiations between the District and the employee's collective bargaining unit are conducted under the pretext that newly agreed upon provisions are intended for the benefit of retaining current employees and the recruitment of future employees. The negotiation process includes compromises in providing monetary increases to some provisions within the compensation and benefits package as well as cost containment or employee contributions to other provisions within the package. Past employees are not represented at the table and therefore are not subject to either side of the compromises agreed upon, whether those are increases in provisions or additional costs to the employees. Employees who retire from the District are subject to the compensation and benefits package, and all other provisions available and which had been agreed upon and in place at the time of retirement. Subsequent negotiations, agreements and MOUs do of apply to individuals not employed by the District or in this case who are no longer members of the collective bargaining unit at the time of the agreement unless otherwise explicitly agreed upon. Former employees and retirees are not members of IBEW 1245 and do not pay dues, so it is curious as to why IBEW 1245 takes the position that it bargained on behalf of them. • Title 14 of the MOU, Grievance Procedures stipulates that an employee, and/or an employee organization official if desired by the employee, shall refer the issue in witting. The District contends that both the original grievance received on February 5, 2020, and the second grievance received on April 14, 2020 have been submitted by IBEW 1245 on behalf of ex-employees, not employees, who are no longer members of the collective bargaining unit, and therefore not covered by the current MOU. In other words, the Union had no standing to submit these grievances. During the informal meeting held between the District's labor negotiating team and IBEW 1245 representatives, Staff indicated that one of the contributing factors of the dispute is whether IBEW 1245 had standing to submit the grievance, as it has been submitted on behalf of a group IBEW 1245 does not represent. Moving directly to advisory arbitration was recommended during this meeting to determine the validity of the grievance and avoid re-opening negotiations which would have financial implications to represented employees. Page 80 of 215 • During the negotiations, the District's negotiating team received parameters from the Board to include modest increases in the District's contribution to employees monthly post retirement medical benefits in exchange for cost containment measures in the form of monthly employee contributions to group medical insurance plans. Neither of these provisions were intended to be applied to previously retired employees. 4. FISCAL IMPACT The direct fiscal impact associated with this item is not yet known, as it is dependent upon the direction provided by the Board. The following potential fiscal impacts have been outlined for consideration: • If the grievance is rejected there will be no direct fiscal impact associated with this item. The District will be subject to equal share with the collective bargaining unit for the cost of advisory arbitration should IBEW 1245 choose to pursue that option. The actual cost of arbitration is not known at this time. • If the grievance is accepted and the Board determines it appropriate to apply the negotiated increases in the District's contributions to post retirement medical benefits to all past retirees, there will be an estimated annual increase in the District's Other Post Employment Benefits (OPEB) of approximately $50,000 - $75,000/year. This annual cost estimate is dependent upon the number of retirees in the program and eligible contributions each year. 5. RECOMMENDATION Staff recommendation is to reject the grievance submitted by IBEW 1245 on April 14, 2020. Brian Wright Michael D. Holley Water Utility Director/Assistant GM General Manager Page 81 of 215 Attachment 1 May 5, 2020 Jeff Bender Board President,TDPUD Board of Directors Truckee Donner PUD 11570 Donner Pass Road Truckee, CA 96161 Dear Mr. Bender, As you may be aware, IBEW 1245 and Truckee Donner PUD are currently in dispute over the applicability of the recently negotiated, December 2019, retiree medical cap increase contained in Title 19 of the Memorandum of Understanding between IBEW 1245 and TDPUD. The retiree medical cap increase was included in a Tentative Agreement (TA), that was presented to and agreed upon by the Board from the District's outside counsel,Joe Wiley,on December 12, 2019, the last day of bargaining. With the understanding of approval of the TA from the Board, at the Union's next unit meeting on December 17, 2019, a ratification vote was held, and the TA was successfully passed by the Union membership. On January 1, 2020, the economic provisions of the TA, approved by the Board and accepted by the membership, were implemented by the District, including the retiree medical cap increase, which was accordingly, paid to all retirees. In early February 2020,the Union became aware that the District would not continue to pay the retiree medical cap increase to current retirees, in contravention of what was bargained and ratified by the Union's membership. Consequently, on February 5, 2020, a grievance was filed on behalf of the retirees. This led to the discovery that although the Board had approved and agreed to the TA, it had not been "formally adopted" in an open meeting, which made the grievance premature. Based on this information,the Union withdrew its grievance on February 12, 2020,with the intention of refiling once the dispute became ripe. On the morning of February 20, 2020, an informal meeting was scheduled to discuss the issue. In attendance were General Manager Michael Holley,Water Utility Director Brian Wright, IBEW 1245 Assistant Business Manager Al Fortier and IBEW 1245 Business Representative Mike Venturino. During the meeting, Mr. Holley conveyed in confidence that the cancellation of payment to current retirees was due to outside pressure from unrepresented retirees. He further stated that the Board was inclined not to approve the TA until the parties had resolved the discrepancy. However, no resolution was reached at that meeting. Page 82 of 215 Another meeting was scheduled for February 25, 2020,to further discuss the issue. The attendees included outside counsel for the District,Joe Wiley,Water Utility Director Brian Wright, Electric Utility Director Joe Horvath, IBEW Assistant Business Manager Al Fortier and Business Representative Mike Venturino. During the meeting, the parties agreed that they would execute a side letter agreement that would include terms for resolving the retiree medical cap increase through the grievance process, so that the TA could be adopted by the Board. This was executed by the District and the Union on March 3, 2020 and March 5, 2020, respectively. With the side letter agreement in place,the TA was finally presented to and adopted by the Board at its March 18, 2020 meeting. Following the adoption of the TA by the Board, the Union refilled its grievance on behalf of the retirees on April 14, 2020. In accordance with Title 14 of the MOU, the Union requested an informal meeting with the General Manager to discuss the grievance. It was the Union's expectation, based on the language of Title 14, that it would receive a response from the General Manager regarding this request. However, on April 15, 2020 the Union received acknowledgement of receipt the grievance from Brian Wright, Acting General Manager—not Michael Holley, General Manger—referring the matter to the District's outside counsel,Joe Wiley. In his April 16, 2020 response, Mr. Wiley states that "rather than go through the traditional steps of the grievance procedure, and based upon our side letter on the issue, I recommend that we proceed directly to arbitration." His proposal to expedite the grievance to arbitration, however, is not what the parties agreed to in the side letter agreement, nor is such action contemplated within Title 14. During the events described above,there was a Board meeting held on April 15, 2020. Among the agenda items for this meeting was "Action Item#13," which pertains to District Code 4, Personnel. Title 4, chapter 4.07 outlines the provisions for employee benefits such as retirement, medical leave and insurance. During the March 18, 2020 Board meeting Resolution 2020-09 was adopted. The April 15, 2020 meeting was to further clarify District Code 4, Chapter 4.07.050, Post-Retirement Health Benefits under Resolution 2020-10 to fall in line with the amounts bargained in December 2019. This was quickly removed from the agenda by Mr. Holley and no action was taken. It is the Union's understanding that any increases to the retiree medical caps negotiated over the years have always been afforded to current retirees, as Title 19, (19.2) (1) 2 allows. However, seeking a middle ground,on or about April 16, 2020, the Union proposed that the District pay the increase to all current retirees for the term of the current MOU, 2019-2024, but that starting January 1, 2025, increases would go solely to members who retired on or after that date. In the Union's estimation,this is both an equitable and reasonable solution. Not Page 83 of 215 only does it uphold the parties' mutual intent at the bargaining table, it also resolves the current grievance and provides the District with an end date. Please advise whether the Union's proposal is acceptable. Sincerely, „t..� MI a Venturino Business Representative IBEW 1245 Page 84 of 215 J 'J 111� 4• TO: Michael Holley GM, TDPUD IBEW Local 1245 FROM: Mike Venturino—Business Representative Local 1245 TDPUD Grievance Form Date: 4/14/20 grievance# 01-2020 STATEMENT OF FACT IBEW is submitting a grievance pursuant to the Memorandum of Understanding between the Truckee Donner PUD and IBEW L.U. 1245, Titlel4 Grievance Procedure. On or about April 1, 2020, TDPUD failed to make appropriate retiree medical payments in accordance with the MOU. SECTION OF MOU VIOLATED TITLE 19 EMPLOYEE BENEFIT PROGRAM, and all other applicable Titles, Policies and/or Procedures (1) Post-Retirement Medical and Dental Benefits: REQUESTED REMEDY OF GRIEVANCE The Union requests that the District cease practice of violating the MOU and make the retirees whole for all losses. IBEW 1245 Representative: Page 85 of 215 (1) Post Retirement Medical and Dental Benefits: (1) To be eligible to receive post-retirement health benefits, an employee must have at least ten (10) years of service with the District. Years of service is defined as cumulative years of service with the District, which may or may not be consecutive years. Employees, who retire from the District and meet the service requirement stated above, will receive a District contribution towards their post-retirement health benefits premium with the insurance company that is contracted for retiree benefits with the District at the time of the employee's retirement, [or to an HRA Heath Reimbursement Account as indicated below] as follows: Percent of Premium Paid Years of Service by District 10 50% 11 55% 12 60% 13 65% 14 70% 15 75% 16 80% 17 85% 18 90% 19 95% 20 100% The post-retirement plan is the same as the active employees' medical plan except for a $500 deductible per person compared to a $400 deductible per person for employees. Retirees may choose the High Deductible Health Plan as a lower cost alternative to the PPO plan. For example, a person retiring at age 55 with 19 years of service would have 95% of the retiree and dependent caps paid by the District. (2) The benefit paid by the District is capped as listed below: Monthly Caps Individual only $ 600 Spouse only $ 600 Child(ren) only $ 600 Spouse & child(ren) only $ 1,000 Medicare Rate $ 500 If the premiums increase above the monthly cap, the retiree will pay the difference between the new premium and their percent of benefit established upon retirement multiplied by the cap. Example:A person retiring at age 55 with 19 years of service would have 95% of the retiree and dependent caps paid by the District. If initially the premium for individual only was$340, the retiree would pay 340—(95%x$340) _ $17.00 If the premium increases to $500 while the cap is$475, the retiree would Page 86 of 215 pay 500— (95% x$475) _ $48.75. (3) Retiree cannot leave the plan and then come back. Once time is broken on the plan, the employee or retiree cannot come back on the medical plan. (4) If the retiree is paying for part of the medical coverage it will be done through an electronic fund transfer from the retiree's account on a monthly basis. (5) When the retiree is eligible for Medicare, it is mandatory that the retiree enroll for Medicare Part B coverage. (6) Should the District change the insurance plans or coverage through the collective bargaining process, those will apply to retirees also. (7) The vision benefit will remain the same without any monthly caps. Page 87 of 215 SIDE LETTER AGREEMENT This Side Letter Agreement is entered into between Truckee Donner Public Utility District ("TDPUD")and IBEW Local 1245. WHEREAS a dispute has arisen as to whether the parties intended in their Tentative Agreement dated December 13,2020 regarding an increase in the Retiree Medical Benefit Cap Payments to extend the increase in the Retiree Medical Benefit Cap Payments to those persons retired prior to January 1,2020; WHEREAS the successor Memorandum of Understanding("MOU")has not yet been adopted by the TDPUD Board of Directors; WHEREAS the parties seek to resolve this dispute without further meet and confer and by allowing the Board of Directors to adopt the proposed Memorandum of Understanding, notwithstanding the present dispute regarding interpretation of the terms of the December 13, 2020 Tentative Agreement,and without either party waiving their respective positions relating to the above dispute. NOW THEREFORE, the parties agree as follows: 1. If the Board of Directors adopts the proposed MOU, there shall be no adverse inference regarding the Board's action. 2. The parties agree to submit the dispute regarding the intent of the Tentative Agreement regarding the increase in the Retiree Medical Benefit Cap Payments for resolution under Title 14,Grievance Procedure,of the Memorandum of Understanding. 3. By entering into this Agreement,neither party waives any procedural or substantive arguments it may have regarding the prosecution or defense of this disagreement. Dated: /j " 3 ' ZC � Dated: -/✓'�/ `� t By: " _ By:-4��/ For noe Donner Public Utility is ict For IBEW 1245 Page 88 of 215 Truckee Donner Public Utility District Directors Joseph R. Aguera Jeff Bender Bob Ellis Christa Finn Tony Laliotis General Manager Michael D. Holley May 8, 2020 Mr. Michael J. Venturino Business Representative IBEW Local 1245 30 Orange Tree Circle Vacaville, CA 95687 Subject: Response to Board Referral Letter Received from IBEW 1245 on May 5, 2020 Dear Mr. Venturino: The Truckee Donner Public Utility District Board of Directors (Board) has received a letter of referral for a grievance submitted on April 14, 2020 from IBEW 1245. The letter of referral to the Board was received on May 5,2020,one day prior to the regularly scheduled meeting held on May 6,2020. Because the letter was received after the meeting agenda had already been published, the item could not be included on the agenda for Board consideration. The District is willing to place the item on the agenda for the regularly scheduled meeting on May 20, 2020. This will require IBEW 1245 to provide a written waiver of the requirement for the Board's written response within ten (10) working days of the next regularly scheduled Board meeting as prescribed in MOU Title 14, section 14.4, Step 3. If IBEW 1245 chooses not to provide the written waiver, then the item shall not be placed on the agenda for consideration within the ten(10)day requirement and the union may move to Step 4 of the grievance procedures, referral to Advisory Arbitration. If IBEW 1245 chooses to provide the written waiver for the Board to review the item in open session, the written waiver and any additional supporting materials intended to be included in the Board packet for consideration must be received by the District no later than 5:OOpm on Wednesday, May 13cn Respectfully, Brian Wright Water Utility Director(Acting General Manager) cc: Sharma Kuhlemier, District Clerk 11570 Donner Pass Road,Truckee, CA 96161 —Phone 530-587-3896—www.tdpud.org Page 89 of 215 May 12, 2020 Mr. Brian Wright, Acting General Manager Truckee Donner PUD 11570 Donner Pass Road Truckee, CA 96161 Subject: Waiver, 10-Day Written Response Requirement,TDPUD Board of Directors, MOU Title 14, (14.4) Step 3 Dear Mr. Wright, The Union hereby agrees to waive the 10-day written response requirement, set forth in Title 14, (14.4) Step 3 of the MOU, as requested in the District's letter received May 8, 2020, on the condition that the Union's Letter of Referral and Grievance will be placed on the agenda and considered by the Board in open session at its next regularly scheduled meeting of May 20, 2020. Furthermore, this agreement (and the Union's waiver) shall establish no precedent. Respectfully, 9aAa*zF--- - Mike Venturino Business Representative IBEW 1245 Page 90 of 215 REGULAR MEETING MINUTES May 20, 2020 1. CALL TO ORDER The meeting of the Board of Directors of the Truckee Donner Public Utility District was called to order at 6:00 p.m. in the TDPUD Boardroom by President Bender. Disclaimer: Due to the COVID-19 situation and the California Governor's Executive Orders, this Board meeting was conducted with the Board via video/teleconferencing measures and live streamed on the District website. Public comment was opened using email and questions and answers on Zoom. 2. ROLL CALL Directors: Tony Laliotis, Joe Aguera, Bob Ellis, Vice President Finn, and Pres- ident Bender. Absent: Director Joe Aguera. EMPLOYEES PRESENT: Brian Wright, Ian Fitzgerald, Steven Poncelet, Mike Salmon, Joe Horvath, Michael Holley, and Shanna Kuhlemier. CONSULTANTS PRESENT — Steve Gross, District Counsel and Pam Hobday, Pamela Hurt Associates. OTHERS PRESENT— 3. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE—defer. 4. CHANGES TO THE AGENDA 5. PUBLIC INPUT President Bender called for public comment, seeing none. President Bender closed public comment. 6. DIRECTOR UPDATE Vice President Finn — • Sent best wishes to Director Aguera who was unable to attend the meeting. • Stated appreciation for technology through this crazy time. • Is focused on future goals for the PUD to keep in mind. Items like climate change and renewable energy are areas to focus. Director Ellis • Stated appreciation of the health of the community. Director Laliotis • Glad to see businesses starting to open and showing respect for social distancing. • Appreciated everyone's efforts in doing the right thing. President Bender Page 91 of 215 • Appreciated the businesses opening according to protocols. PUBLIC HEARING 7. Conduct Public Hearing Related to Adoption of District Resolutions 2020-12, 2020-13, 2020-14, and 2020-15 for Annual Electric and Water Standby Charges Mike Salmon provided a presentation (available upon request). President Bender opened the public hearing to hear testimony in support or opposition of the District's Annual standby changes. Seeing none, President Bender closed the public hearing. Board Comments: • Discussion on cost of service and these long time fees. With a cost of service analysis underway for water and electric. The Board directed to staff to include these fees. o Keeping in mind a proposition 218 process would apply to increase these fees. Director Laliotis moved, and Director Ellis seconded, that the Board approve the staff recom- mendation. The motion passed unanimously (4-0), by a roll call vote. Director Aguera was absent. CONSENT CALENDAR 8. Consideration of Resolutions to Consolidate the General Election on November 3, 2020. 9. Consideration to Adopt Resolution 2020-11 to Close-Out the SCADA Reliability Improve- ment Project Phase 5. 10.Consideration to Appoint a Treasurer for the District. 11.Consideration of a Contract to Perform Geotechnical Testing Services. President Bender called for public comment, there were none. Director Ellis moved, and Vice President Finn seconded, that the Board approve the Consent Calendar. The motion passed unanimously (4-0), by a roll call vote. Director Aguera was ab- sent. ACTION 12.Consideration of the Letter of Referral Submitted by IBEW 1245 Regarding a Grievance per the Memorandum of Understanding with IBEW 1245 (MOU). Brian Wright provided a presentation (available upon request). President Bender called for public comment. District Clerk Kuhlemier read into the record the name of those who provided public comments submitted for consideration and those names who provided public comment on March 18, 2020. Board Comments: Page 92 of 215 • Thanked everyone for their comments and emails. Each Director provided input on receiving and reading every public comment provided. • District Code outlines the policy clearly and concisely. Being sensitive to comments and concerns, the Code and interpretation is clear. • The presentation was through and aligns with negotiation updates to the Board. • Stated a trust in staff and legal counsel. o Updates did not include retired employees nor persons not employed by the District. • Appreciated the process that is outlined in code and the MOU, the presentation clearly depicts what the Board understood through negotiations. • The District negotiates with employees. The District has never negotiated with or for retirees. • The District needs to control cost of the public's money. • An explanation of staffing administration error in January for retirees. • Does the Union represent women? Brian Wright answered, IBEW1245 represents hard working women in the District. President Bender noted that IBEW1245 should consider gender neutrality in their name to in- clude women. • Assurances that every comment was read and considered prior to the meeting. President Bender noted Mike Venturino was making a comment during the meeting that was inaudible. General Counsel Gross stated the Union had the opportunity to submit information for the agenda item. The District clearly and legally stated what the mechanism was for public com- ment. President Bender requested Mr. Venturino's comments during the presentation be read into the record. Those comments are as follows: Michael Venturino 06:41 PM Hello? Michael Venturino 06:40 PM Mike Venturino, IBEW is on the video chat but apparently cannot be heard Michael Venturino 06:42 PM I can see the video and hear the video, but appaently i cannot be heard Michael Venturino 06:43 PM correct Michael Venturino 06:44 PM I would ask the Board review my submission, to Brian Michael Venturino 06:44 PM In the Board packet there should have been a submission Michael Venturino 06:45 PM can type, but it will take several minutes as I do not quickly Michael Venturino 06:45 PM type quickly Michael Venturino 06:46 PM The highlightes section is very clear and unambiguous. Page 93 of 215 Michael Venturino 06:46 PM sorry, highlighted Michael Venturino 06:47 PM the increaase was a change in coverage, and will apply to retirees Michael Venturino 06:48 PM The side letter only stipulates that Title 14 would be followed, not go straight to arbitration as suggested by Mr. Wright Michael Venturino 06:49 PM Retirees are a permissive subject of bargaining and without specifically "excluding" them from bargaining, they would then be included. Michael Venturino 06:50 PM Why then are current retirees being paid as per the most current MOU? Michael Venturino 06:52 PM A resolution that is favorable to both the Union and the District is proposed in the last para- graph of the letter of referral. It is fair and reasonable and limits the Districts liability going forwARD. Please read! Michael Venturino 06:53 PM Thank you Mr. Gross Michael Venturino 06:54 PM was not aware I would not be able to spe Vice President Finn moved, and President Bender seconded, that the Board approve the staff recommendation. The motion passed unanimously (4-0), by a roll call vote. Director Aguera was absent. 13.Consideration of a Contract to Perform the Water Meter Radio Transmitter Replacement Project. Brian Wright proved a presentation (available upon request). President Bender called for public comment, there were none. Director Ellis moved, and Vice President Finn seconded, that the Board approve the staff rec- ommendation. The motion passed unanimously (4-0), by a roll call vote. Director Aguera was absent. 14.Consideration of a Contract to Complete the Tank Site Piping Modifications Project. This item concerns a contract with Longo Incorporated in an amount not to exceed $321,500. Brian Wright proved a presentation (available upon request). President Bender called for public comment, there were none. Director Laliotis moved, and Director Ellis seconded, that the Board approve the staff recom- mendation. The motion passed unanimously (4-0), by a roll call vote. Director Aguera was absent. Page 94 of 215 President Bender called a recess at 7:27 p.m. The Board reconvened at 7:35 p.m. WORKSHOP 15.Review the Proposed Water Utility Ten Year Capital Improvement Plan. This item involves review of the proposed updated Water Utility Ten Year Capital Im- provement Plan. Brian Wright proved a presentation (available upon request). President Bender called for public comment, there were none. Board Comments: • A large tool for the Board to use for the rate study • Large numbers but informative to work with staff and prioritize. • Resilience and sustainability are in every project the District embarks on. o How does the Board meet these goals strategically? o The Town approved a 100% renewable resolution. The first project the Town embarked on did not fit the resolution and commitment. o Wants the Board to set the standard and ensure we meet our commitments. • There are opportunities to shape the plan and the future of the District. • Use the rate study to prioritize this plan • This is an opportunity to leverage the District in the future. 16.Review of the District's COVID-19 Relief Efforts. This item involves an update to the Board on the COVID-19 Relief Program. Steven Poncelet proved a presentation (available upon request). President Bender called for public comment, there were none. Board Comments: • Continue to work closely with business partners in need of help. • Ideas for business customers. o Introduced staff's idea to help mid-level customers. ROUTINE BUSINES 17. Treasurer's Report: May 2020. a) Approval of the Treasurer's report of fund balances for the Month Ended March 2020. President Bender called for public comment, there were none. Director Ellis moved, and Director Laliotis seconded, that the Board approve the staff recom- mendation. The motion passed unanimously (4-0), by a roll call vote. Director Aguera was absent. Page 95 of 215 b) Approval of disbursements for April 2020. President Bender called for public comment, there were none. Director Laliotis moved, and Director Ellis seconded, that the Board approve the staff recom- mendation. The motion passed unanimously (4-0), by a roll call vote. Director Aguera was absent. 18.Approval of the Minutes of May 6, 2020 President Bender called for public comment, there were none. Director Ellis moved, and President Bender seconded that the Board approve the minutes. The motion passed unanimously (4-0), by a roll call vote. Director Aguera was absent. CLOSED SESSION —8:35 p.m. 19.Closed Session Pursuant to Government Code Section 54957.6, Conference with Labor Negotiators: Agency designated representatives: President, Jeff Bender; and Director, Tony Laliotis Unrepresented employee: General Manager No reportable action. 20.Closed Session Pursuant to Government Code Section 54957, Public Employee Perfor- mance Evaluation — General Manager's Performance Plan Review. No reportable action. ADJOURNMENT- 10:07 p.m. There being no further business before the Board, the meeting was adjourned to the next scheduled regularly scheduled meeting of the Truckee Donner Public Utility District on June 3, 2020 at 6:00 p.m. TRUCKEE RP IC UTILITY DISTRICT Jeff Ben er, sident Respectfully Submitted, Shanna D. Kuhlemier, CIVIC, District Clerk Page 96 of 215