HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem 7. Trout Unlimited June 16, 2025
To: Board Members, Truckee Donner Public Utility District
From: Trout Unlimited, Truckee River Chapter
RE: Public Comment for Agenda Item 7.1, June 18 Board Meeting
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Trout Unlimited's mission is to protect, restore, reconnect, and sustain cold-water fisheries for
the benefit of future generations. This mission is implemented in part through the local
chapters of TU. The Truckee River chapter represents the North Lake Tahoe region, and we are
a designated member of the Martis Valley Groundwater Management Plan's Stakeholder
Working Group. We appreciate the opportunity to comment on the 2025 update of the Martis
Valley Groundwater Management Plan.
In Martis Valley, waters we are concerned about specifically include Alder Creek, Cold Creek,
Donner Creek, Martis Creek and tributaries, Martis Creek Lake, Prosser Creek and tributaries,
Prosser Creek Reservoir, Trout Creek, and the Truckee River. We are also interested in the
springs and seeps that feed our local streams and lakes, and in groundwater levels that
maintain fish-friendly stream flows during the dry months of summer and autumn.
The Truckee River Chapter of Trout Unlimited very much wishes that, as a designated MVGMP
stakeholder, our perspective had been sought at the beginning of the plan update process,
rather than at its conclusion. In 2013, the MVGMP missed the issue of fisheries health, and this
lack of attention remains true for the 2025 update that is now under consideration for
approval. To help rectify this omission, we recommend the edits below.
Planning Process
Section 1.3. Groundwater Management Plan Development Process, page 4: Change the
opening of Step 1 to read, "Step 1— Provide public notification of a hearing on whether or not
to adopt a resolution of intention to draft a GMP and subsequently complete a hearing on
whether or not to adopt a resolution of intention to draft a GMP. Notification shall include
direct contact with each stakeholder of the Stakeholder Working Group." (Italics show
suggested text.)
Rationale: Future updates of the GMP need to better consider stakeholder issues. To
assist with this objective, the GMP should require the water agencies to tell stakeholders that
they are beginning the GMP update process. Stakeholders were unaware of the current update
until very late in the planning process. A best-management practice is to bring stakeholders
early into public-sector planning processes.
Section 1.3. Groundwater Management Plan Development Process, page 5: Change the
opening of Step 3 to read, "Step 3— Prepare a draft GMP within two years of resolution of
intention adoption.At the initiation of the update process, seek to understand the concerns of
stakeholders through direct contact and one or more meetings."
Rationale: To help ensure basin issues are identified and discussed adequately,
stakeholders should be engaged as soon as possible in the update process, rather than at its
conclusion.
Section 1.7. Public Outreach and Education, page 9: Replace the existing text with "For each
update of the GMP, the partner agencies shall develop a Public Outreach Plan to guide
development of the update. To ensure stakeholder interests are understood, members of the
Stakeholder Working Group shall be brought into the planning process prior to initiation of the
first draft of the update
Rationale: Section 1.7 should be rewritten to invite stakeholder participation early in the
planning process. With the current 2025 update, outreach to stakeholders consisted of two
emails that were sent at the end of the planning process
Descriptions of Conditions
The recommended text edits that follow below will improve the accuracy and completeness of
statements in the 2025 MVGMP, thereby enhancing their usefulness for policy makers and
agency/consultant staff.
Section 2.3.1 Truckee River, page 16: Add a third paragraph with the following text: "During
late 2020 and into the autumn of 2021, a pumping depression formed in Truckee north of the
Truckee River, and water from the river may have been pulled into the aquifer in this area. The
effect of groundwater pumping elsewhere on Truckee River flows is not known."
Section 2.3.2 Martis Creek, page 21: Add a fourth paragraph with the following text: "The
groundwater level at a CASEGEM well in the Mortis Creek watershed shows seasonal
fluctuations that correlate strongly with groundwater pumping. The effect of groundwater
pumping elsewhere in the watershed, or on the flow of perennial streams, is not known."
Section 2.3.3.1 Cold Creek, page 21: Add to the end of the paragraph the following text:
"Portions of the stream channel can experience seasonal dewatering. The effect of groundwater
pumping on stream flow is not known."
Section 2.3.4 Trout Creek, page 22: Add to the end of the paragraph the following text: "Trout
Creek south of Interstate 80 is the site of extensive stream restoration work financed by the
Town of Truckee and the State of California. Some years, the stream channel in the area of
Truckee's historical railyard can become dewatered. The effect of groundwater pumping on
stream flow is not known."
Section 2.5.3. Groundwater Levels, page 36: Replace the second sentence in the second bullet
statement (re well B001M) with: "Seasonal, production-related fluctuations have continued,
with no recovery to pre-development water elevations."
Section 2.5.3. Groundwater Levels, page 37: Replace the existing text with the following: "TH-
Fibreboard and TH-Prosser Village have experienced recent seasonal fluctuations that deviate
from earlier norms. These fluctuations correlate strongly with water production, but might also
reflect complications with nearby faults."
Basin Management Objectives
The Trout Unlimited Chapter of Trout Unlimited is disappointed with the MVGMP's tepid
language regarding environmental protection and with its lack of language regarding the
protection, as required by the State of California, of groundwater-dependent ecosystems and
the beneficial uses of surface waters. Please rectify this omission, which we consider serious. At
the very least, we recommend adding where appropriate this simple, clear statement: "A
purpose of this plan is to prevent groundwater pumping from significantly harming
groundwater-dependent ecosystems and the riparian habitats and fish populations of Martis
Valley's surface waters."